Too Faced The Return of Sexy Review +Swatches

By | Thursday, October 23, 2014 4 comments

This set comes with 15 eyeshadows, a black pencil eyeliner, deluxe sized Too Faced Shadow Insurance eye primer and 3 cards with detailed instructions on how to create specific eyeshadow looks. However I'm only going to review the palette (feeling lazy today)

The palette case is a very sturdy hard plastic with a mirror inside and a slot for the eyeshadow look cards to slide behind the mirror. This is a very handy feature for keeping the cards close at hand, but out of the way. The case snaps closed securely and in the short time I've had it, I've already dropped it several times, but nothing inside has cracked. 

All of the shadows in this palette are shimmery with the exception of the shade "pink diamond" They're all soft and silky in texture, but also have an annoying amount of fall out when used without a primer. However the colors are so gorgeously pigmented that I'm willing to overlook the fall out, lol. 
The eyeshadows in this palette are broken up into sections (The Bombshell, The Icon and The Ingenue) with each section containing a certain "color story" All of the shadows were swatched without primer.

Overall The Return of Sexy set is a great value for the amount/quality of the eyeshadows, the eyeliner and eye shadow primer. It retails for $49 and is available at Sephora!
Newer Post Older Post Home


  1. Nice pigmented swatches. I have yet to try any of their shadows...they are next on my list though :-)

  2. Thanks! This is the second palette I've brought from too faced and I'm loving them so far. You should definitely check them out! I've been eyeing the Chocolate Bar palette as my next purchase...

  3. Yes, the chocolate bar is the one I'm looking's on HSN with the easy pay option. I've been eyeing it but I have so many other palettes that I don't use as much as I like.

  4. I know what you mean! Eyeshadow palettes are my weakness, even though I already have more than I could ever use, lol